$2.99$3.99

Typical priceChecked Jul 12

MicroPerfumesTrusted

Buy now Compare all 5 prices Compare 5 prices

We may earn a commission.

By the Fireplace

Q: Is By the Fireplace too smoky to wear in public?

It depends on your tolerance for smoke-forward fragrances, but most wearers find it falls on the cozy side of smoky rather than the aggressive side — at least initially. The sillage is moderate rather than overwhelming, so it's unlikely to clear a room. That said, a small number of people find the smoke becomes more intense and less polished with skin chemistry or after repeated wears, so a sample test before committing to a full bottle is worth doing.

Q: Is this fragrance actually unisex, or does it wear more masculine or feminine?

It's marketed as unisex and genuinely functions that way, though the combination of smoke, spice, and wood does give it a slightly warmer, more traditionally masculine feel. The vanilla and cashmeran in the base balance that out and make it comfortable for anyone. Community wear skews across genders without much debate about it feeling out of place on either.

Q: How does the longevity compare to other Replica fragrances?

By the Fireplace is generally considered one of the stronger performers in the Replica line, which has a reputation for inconsistent longevity across its range. It typically lasts through a full day or evening, though it fades to a quiet skin scent by the end rather than staying full-volume. If you've struggled with other Replicas disappearing quickly, this one tends to hold up better.

Q: What occasions is this best suited for?

This is firmly an evening and nighttime fragrance for fall and winter — it fits casual evenings in, nights out in cold weather, and any setting where warmth and comfort are the goal. It's not a great fit for professional or warm-weather contexts, and the community largely treats it as a seasonal specialty rather than an everyday driver.

Q: How does it compare to other warm, sweet winter fragrances on the market?

By the Fireplace occupies an interesting middle ground — it's sweeter than a straight woody smoke but more complex than a simple vanilla gourmand. The chestnut and cade juniper give it a specificity that sets it apart from fragrances that just layer vanilla over wood. It's frequently recommended to people who want warmth and sweetness but find most vanilla fragrances too soft or one-dimensional.

Q: Has By the Fireplace been reformulated since its 2015 launch?

There's no widely documented reformulation that has significantly altered the fragrance's character, and community discussion doesn't reflect the kind of before/after debate that typically surfaces when a beloved scent changes. If performance concerns come up, they tend to be attributed to individual skin chemistry or expectations for the Replica line generally rather than a shift in formula.

Maison Margiela·2015·Eau De Toilette

from $2.99· Checked Jul 12 Compare

$2.99$3.99

Typical priceChecked Jul 12

MicroPerfumesTrusted

Buy now Compare all 5 prices Compare 5 prices

We may earn a commission.

Accords

Notes

TopPink pepper//Clove//Orange blossom absolute

HeartGaiac wood//Chestnut//Cade juniper

BaseVanilla//Peru balsam//Cashmeran

Where to buy By the Fireplace

from $2.99 (<5ml) · 3 retailers

Every retailer shown here is a seller we’ve vetted.

30ml

Checked Jul 11

MicroPerfumes

$54.00$120.00Buy

FragranceNet

$66.49Buy

Today's best price of $54.00 is about the typical price for this size, based on 25 days of tracking.

<5ml

Checked Jul 12

MicroPerfumes

$2.99$3.99Buy

MicroPerfumes

$12.99$14.99Buy

eCosmetics

$17.81Buy

Today's best price of $2.99 is about the typical price for this size, based on 27 days of tracking.

Price history

<5ml price trendAt tracked low of $2.99

Amazon

Price not trackedBuy

Get on the early list. We'll email you as this rolls out.

Prices are collected from third-party retailers and updated periodically. Always verify the price on the retailer's site before purchasing. We may earn a commission on purchases made through our links.

What does By the Fireplace smell like?

By the Fireplace opens with a jolt of spice — pink pepper and clove arrive sharp and crackling, like the first moment a fire catches. Orange blossom absolute adds a subtle sweetness underneath that ke...

Details

House: Maison Margiela
Concentration: Eau De Toilette
Gender: unisex
Year: 2015
Longevity: 7.8 / 10
Sillage: 7.4 / 10
Scent Profile: Smoky, Sweet, Woody, Spicy, Gourmand
Best Seasons: Winter, Fall
Best Occasions: Evening, Night Out
Perfumer: Marie Salamagne

Community Insights

Based on 403 discussions

The opening smoke is almost universally praised as realistic and evocative, but a small contingent find that after repeated wears, the smoke element tips from cozy hearth into full campfire — less "romantic evening by the fire," more "wind blowing smoke directly at you."
This is treated as a quintessential winter and deep fall fragrance — community members consistently reach for it during cold weather, snowstorms, and ski trips, and it rarely gets recommended outside those seasons.
Performance is considered solid for a Replica eau de toilette, which is a line with a mixed longevity reputation. By the Fireplace outperforms several of its stablemates, though it does fade to a light skin scent by the end of its wear.
It's frequently described as the fragrance to reach for when you want to feel smoky rather than sweet, used as a deliberate mood-setter rather than an everyday signature.
The chestnut-and-smoke combination draws comparisons to warm, gourmand-leaning winter fragrances, and it's often held up as a reference point for what a cozy seasonal scent should actually smell like.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is By the Fireplace too smoky to wear in public?+

It depends on your tolerance for smoke-forward fragrances, but most wearers find it falls on the cozy side of smoky rather than the aggressive side — at least initially. The sillage is moderate rather than overwhelming, so it's unlikely to clear a room. That said, a small number of people find the smoke becomes more intense and less polished with skin chemistry or after repeated wears, so a sample test before committing to a full bottle is worth doing.

Is this fragrance actually unisex, or does it wear more masculine or feminine?+

It's marketed as unisex and genuinely functions that way, though the combination of smoke, spice, and wood does give it a slightly warmer, more traditionally masculine feel. The vanilla and cashmeran in the base balance that out and make it comfortable for anyone. Community wear skews across genders without much debate about it feeling out of place on either.

How does the longevity compare to other Replica fragrances?+

By the Fireplace is generally considered one of the stronger performers in the Replica line, which has a reputation for inconsistent longevity across its range. It typically lasts through a full day or evening, though it fades to a quiet skin scent by the end rather than staying full-volume. If you've struggled with other Replicas disappearing quickly, this one tends to hold up better.

Appears in Collections

Date Night Fragrances1836 Evening Fragrances2333 Fall Fragrances492 Winter Fragrances480 Unisex Fragrances3693 Eau de Toilette Fragrances847+ 2 more

Similar Fragrances

Maison Margiela

Lazy Sunday Morning

Eau De Toilette

Maison Francis Kurkdjian

Amyris Homme

Extrait

Gucci

Gucci pour Homme

Eau De Toilette

Roja Parfums

Manhattan

Eau De Parfum

Diptyque

34 Boulevard Saint Germain

Eau De Parfum

M. Micallef

Jewel for Him

Eau De Parfum

Goutal

Encens Flamboyant

Eau De Parfum

Maison Francis Kurkdjian

Amyris Homme

Eau De Cologne

from $2.99· Checked Jul 12 Compare

$2.99$3.99

Typical priceChecked Jul 12

MicroPerfumesTrusted

Buy now Compare all 5 prices Compare 5 prices

We may earn a commission.

$2.99$3.99

Typical priceChecked Jul 12

MicroPerfumesTrusted

Buy now Compare all 5 prices Compare 5 prices

We may earn a commission.

What does By the Fireplace smell like?

By the Fireplace opens with a jolt of spice — pink pepper and clove arrive sharp and crackling, like the first moment a fire catches. Orange blossom absolute adds a subtle sweetness underneath that ke...

Details

House: Maison Margiela
Concentration: Eau De Toilette
Gender: unisex
Year: 2015
Longevity: 7.8 / 10
Sillage: 7.4 / 10
Scent Profile: Smoky, Sweet, Woody, Spicy, Gourmand
Best Seasons: Winter, Fall
Best Occasions: Evening, Night Out
Perfumer: Marie Salamagne

Community Insights

Based on 403 discussions

The opening smoke is almost universally praised as realistic and evocative, but a small contingent find that after repeated wears, the smoke element tips from cozy hearth into full campfire — less "romantic evening by the fire," more "wind blowing smoke directly at you."
This is treated as a quintessential winter and deep fall fragrance — community members consistently reach for it during cold weather, snowstorms, and ski trips, and it rarely gets recommended outside those seasons.
Performance is considered solid for a Replica eau de toilette, which is a line with a mixed longevity reputation. By the Fireplace outperforms several of its stablemates, though it does fade to a light skin scent by the end of its wear.
It's frequently described as the fragrance to reach for when you want to feel smoky rather than sweet, used as a deliberate mood-setter rather than an everyday signature.
The chestnut-and-smoke combination draws comparisons to warm, gourmand-leaning winter fragrances, and it's often held up as a reference point for what a cozy seasonal scent should actually smell like.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is By the Fireplace too smoky to wear in public?+

It depends on your tolerance for smoke-forward fragrances, but most wearers find it falls on the cozy side of smoky rather than the aggressive side — at least initially. The sillage is moderate rather than overwhelming, so it's unlikely to clear a room. That said, a small number of people find the smoke becomes more intense and less polished with skin chemistry or after repeated wears, so a sample test before committing to a full bottle is worth doing.

Is this fragrance actually unisex, or does it wear more masculine or feminine?+

It's marketed as unisex and genuinely functions that way, though the combination of smoke, spice, and wood does give it a slightly warmer, more traditionally masculine feel. The vanilla and cashmeran in the base balance that out and make it comfortable for anyone. Community wear skews across genders without much debate about it feeling out of place on either.

How does the longevity compare to other Replica fragrances?+

By the Fireplace is generally considered one of the stronger performers in the Replica line, which has a reputation for inconsistent longevity across its range. It typically lasts through a full day or evening, though it fades to a quiet skin scent by the end rather than staying full-volume. If you've struggled with other Replicas disappearing quickly, this one tends to hold up better.

What occasions is this best suited for?+

This is firmly an evening and nighttime fragrance for fall and winter — it fits casual evenings in, nights out in cold weather, and any setting where warmth and comfort are the goal. It's not a great fit for professional or warm-weather contexts, and the community largely treats it as a seasonal specialty rather than an everyday driver.

How does it compare to other warm, sweet winter fragrances on the market?+

By the Fireplace occupies an interesting middle ground — it's sweeter than a straight woody smoke but more complex than a simple vanilla gourmand. The chestnut and cade juniper give it a specificity that sets it apart from fragrances that just layer vanilla over wood. It's frequently recommended to people who want warmth and sweetness but find most vanilla fragrances too soft or one-dimensional.

Has By the Fireplace been reformulated since its 2015 launch?+

There's no widely documented reformulation that has significantly altered the fragrance's character, and community discussion doesn't reflect the kind of before/after debate that typically surfaces when a beloved scent changes. If performance concerns come up, they tend to be attributed to individual skin chemistry or expectations for the Replica line generally rather than a shift in formula.

Accords

Notes

TopPink pepper//Clove//Orange blossom absolute

HeartGaiac wood//Chestnut//Cade juniper

BaseVanilla//Peru balsam//Cashmeran

Where to buy By the Fireplace

from $2.99 (<5ml) · 3 retailers

Every retailer shown here is a seller we’ve vetted.

30ml

Checked Jul 11

MicroPerfumes

$54.00$120.00Buy

FragranceNet

$66.49Buy

Today's best price of $54.00 is about the typical price for this size, based on 25 days of tracking.

<5ml

Checked Jul 12

MicroPerfumes

$2.99$3.99Buy

MicroPerfumes

$12.99$14.99Buy

eCosmetics

$17.81Buy

Today's best price of $2.99 is about the typical price for this size, based on 27 days of tracking.

Price history

<5ml price trendAt tracked low of $2.99

Amazon

Price not trackedBuy

Get on the early list. We'll email you as this rolls out.

Prices are collected from third-party retailers and updated periodically. Always verify the price on the retailer's site before purchasing. We may earn a commission on purchases made through our links.

Similar Fragrances

Maison Margiela

Lazy Sunday Morning

Eau De Toilette

Maison Francis Kurkdjian

Amyris Homme

Extrait

Gucci

Gucci pour Homme

Eau De Toilette

Roja Parfums

Manhattan

Eau De Parfum

Diptyque

34 Boulevard Saint Germain

Eau De Parfum

M. Micallef

Jewel for Him

Eau De Parfum

Goutal

Encens Flamboyant

Eau De Parfum

Maison Francis Kurkdjian

Amyris Homme

Eau De Cologne

Appears in Collections

Date Night Fragrances1836 Evening Fragrances2333 Fall Fragrances492 Winter Fragrances480 Unisex Fragrances3693 Eau de Toilette Fragrances847+ 2 more